Anyone want to hazard a guess? Pics!

[Snappy]

Tony those were my first impressions of them as well.

[Keri]

Yup, I'd buy that. (I googled A. Valida) Can't wait till it starts branching out. Right now it seems to be more focussed on encrusting everything around it. I'm glad I didn't throw it out about a month after I got it I was pretty sure it was dead!

And the other is definiately a monti digi, I wonder why it's stayed so brown? I have a brilliant orange one and a bright green one (thanks Marie!) that have stayed true to colour....maybe that one is just meant to be brown...Maybe I'll call it a "milk-chocoate finger coral" to make myself feel better about it!