New Frag ID Please

[Baldy]

Hello,

I picked up a couple new frags today, and would like some help with IDs please.


I think this one is a type of favia, but im not 100% sure



And I think this is a small chalice coral, but again not sure.






Any Idea?

[Myka]

Favites on the first one (that's diff than Favia), Chalice on the second.

[paddyob]

Does not look like a chalice.

Any links Mindy?

[Myka]

Originally Posted by paddyob

Does not look like a chalice.

Any links Mindy?

"Chalice" includes Oxypora, Pectinia, Echinophyllia and a few others that are less common. Oxypora is the "true" Chalice coral, although we see more Echinos in the hobby so it is what most people recognize as Chalice corals.

I'm pretty sure Levi is right and that it is an Oxypora, so here is a bigger Oxypora photo:

[paddyob]

Originally Posted by Myka

"Chalice" includes Oxypora, Pectinia, Echinophyllia and a few others that are less common. Oxypora is the "true" Chalice coral, although we see more Echinos in the hobby so it is what most people recognize as Chalice corals.

I'm pretty sure Levi is right and that it is an Oxypora, so here is a bigger Oxypora photo:

Thanks. I have been trying to figure this particular coral out for a while without luck. My chalice is much much different.

[Myka]

Originally Posted by paddyob

Thanks. I have been trying to figure this particular coral out for a while without luck. My chalice is much much different.

Post a pic of yours?

[Zoaelite]

Originally Posted by paddyob

Does not look like a chalice.

Any links Mindy?

Almost positive its an oxypora species so Mindys bang on the I'D.

Sent from my HTC Desire HD using Tapatalk

[BMahura]

The first one looks very similar to my christmas favites. im not 100% sure on the chalice but i believe it could be an alien eye chalice

[Baldy]

thanks a lot for the fast replies guys. it has given me a lot more reading to do!

another question i have now, what are signs of healthy or unhealthy frags of each. something tells me there wont be much inflation/deflation of the chalice coral, but maybe color change. the favites i believe ive read should feel kind of "meaty", but mine feel hard like a rock.

[BMahura]

For chalices I find that when mine is happy all of the little mountains on it are rounded as the flesh is slightly inflated. When its not happy they look very sharp. Another thing when they are unhealthy the flesh slowly recedes on the skeleton. By the looks of it your chalice is healthy.