Sand Sifting Starfish

[hfp75]

I need feedback. Usually I research purchases, but I got a 3" sand sifting starfish. Now I read mixed reviews about them and the majority of people say not to get them. I can return it if I need to but do I really need to?

I have a JBJ 24g with about 1.5" of sand.

What do you think? I feed everyday, is it a keeper or a return item?

I like the idea of it.... should I just get another Starfish or skip them all together.

THX