Topic Reply Notification

[Samw]

I keep getting Emails about Topic Reply Notification. However, I have turned it off in my profile and also in the subject. For example, in the Yellow Goby thread, I keep getting notifications when someone posts in it. I don't get a link at the bottom that says "Unwatch topic". I only get an option to "Watch Topic". I assume that if I don't click "Watch Topic", and I have "Always notify me of replies:" set to NO, then I won't get notifications.

What else could it be?