[lastlight]

If everyone shopping there knows it's recycled I have no problem with it.

I think in the end two big questions you need to ask yourself is:

1) how important is your time and

2) how particular are you about your tank. If you want ground/polished edges, really clean and straight joints, no shower door frosting/etching on the inside of your tank, things done right the first time...then choose accordingly. Again I wish I didn't look like I was dwelling on this but when I read the words starfire, black silicone, rimless etc I think of a hobbiest like myself. I've seen (and had) a lot of BVA tanks and I personally wouldn't be happy with one now and I'm trying my best to help out.

If it was in-wall I think it's MUCH less of an issue if you are patient and the glass you end up getting is scratch free.