Hydrometer readings

[mrhasan]

Just wanted to know something from the experience of people who used both hydrometer and refractometer. Hydrometer do give inaccurate reading but is it above or below the actual SG?

[fresh]

It could be either, depending on the hydrometer. You should get yours checked against an accurate refractometer to know exactly how far off, and in which direction your hydrometer reading is.

[Aquattro]

It could be either, depending on the hydrometer. You should get yours checked against an accurate refractometer to know exactly how far off, and in which direction your hydrometer reading is.

However, over time it could change. Just buy a refractometer :)

[mrhasan]

Yah I will but not until the end of August since I will be away for this whole month. My room mate will take care of my tank by feeding the fishes and doing a cup of fresh water top-off every two/three days. So just wanted to make sure that I am getting approximately correct results using the hydrometer so that I can tell him the interval of the top off. I always clean my hydrometer with warm water and vinegar after every use. Any suggestion? :question:

[Myka]

Take it to an LFS and get them to check it for you. I've personally seen them inaccurate by as much as 0.008 in either direction.

[mrhasan]

Yah I was thinking of doing that along with the other parameters too. Any idea how much water I should take to LFS?

[Myka]

100 mL is usually plenty.

[Aquattro]

I had mine tested as being almost completely accurate. It stayed that way for years, until it changed, and by a lot. I ended up running a tank at 1.032 for 4 months. It caused me a lot of grief..

[mrhasan]

100 mL is usually plenty.

Great :D I was thinking like a liter or something :P Silly me!

[mrhasan]

I had mine tested as being almost completely accurate. It stayed that way for years, until it changed, and by a lot. I ended up running a tank at 1.032 for 4 months. It caused me a lot of grief..

4 months? :O That's a long time! So does that means a "out of the scale" salinity will actually take a long time to punch the system?

[Aquattro]

You can get varying issues. Not enough salt, your corals will suffer. I had too much, hence too much Ca, and my sand solidified. Rock solid slab 2x4 ft. Also not good for fish or corals to have too much. For the cost of a refractometer, I'd go get one today before the stores close.

[mrhasan]

Rock solid slab. Haha :P You could have made a table top with that and label it as "live sand table top" :D

[Aquattro]

Rock solid slab. Haha :P You could have made a table top with that and label it as "live sand table top" :D
I broke it into 6 or 7 pieces to remove it. No table :)

[mrhasan]

Jokes apart. That must have really sucked :(

[Aquattro]

Jokes apart. That must have really sucked :(

Ya, I tore the tank down I was so ****ed off! Could have avoided it with a real refractometer :razz:

[toytech]

my frag tank took a face plant this month due to a huge salinity increase caused by a hydrometer , bought a refractometer and figured out sg was .31 when hydrometer said .24 real pain to bring it back down .

[mrhasan]

Looks like hydrometer is more notoriously famous for showing lower reading than higher reading.

[dreef]

If you can't afford 50 bucks for a refractometer your definately in the wrong hobby.

[mrhasan]

I can definitely afford a $50 refractometer but like I said before, I can't get it before the end of August since I will be leaving town shortly and wont get it through shipping :) And there's no $50 refractometer available in the shops (all around $90-$100 and that I can't afford; atleast not a $100 refractometer since there are $40-$50 ones available).

[lpsreefer]

If you like depending on where ya live I can stop by and check for you with my refractometer.

[mrhasan]

Thanks for the offer but actually I will be going to Big Al's tomorrow to get everything tested. Once again, thank you so much for the offer :D