Harlequin Bass (Serranus tigrinus) or ?

[adamsarmywife]

LMAO!!!!! http://fortyfathoms.10.forumer.com/images/smiles/icon_lol.gif

Sorry.... so my friend just got a nano biocube. holds about 8 gallons of water.

Long story short she has a very serious hair algae bloom. No big deal I tell her. We moved the tank etc etc...

So she can't handle waiting to throw something in. She goes local to buy a cuc (o.k.) and comes home with a fish the "guy" :wink: said would fix it.

I look it up and it's a Harlequin Bass (Serranus tigrinus)
or a Spotted Hawkfish (Cirrhitichthys aprinus)


http://liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=15+21+385&pcatid=385 (http://liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=15+21+385&pcatid=385)

or

http://liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=15+34+204&pcatid=204 (http://liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=15+34+204&pcatid=204)
So has anybody ever convinced on of these to eat algae???

Thanks Katy

[dsaundry]

Nice, maybe they should get a hippo tang to go with it too. Nice advice from the lfs :lol:

[fishytime]

you know, stories like this really freakin irk me.........how do the people at the LFSs figure that giving bad advice just to make a sale is a good business practice??????!.....I have literally lost sales because Im honest with people, and I think customers appreciate that.....Heres an example from back before I worked at a LFS and was a hobbyist and shopped around more......I was in a LFS once admiring a tank full of little wee 1-2" regal tangs when the LFS guy came and asked me what size my tank was.....at the time it was a 20g tank and I told him this.....he said " oh ya these fish would be great in a 20g".......Im thinking to myself" I didnt just fall off the reef truck and you just lost my business"......I literally have never bought one single thing from that store because of that bad advice......of course the advice shouldnt really have surprised me considering the same LFS has a small regal and yellow tang in a 14g bio-cube......

[rtram]

neither of those fish will eat algae.

[High tide]

How do you know what kind of fish it is, if it could be two completely different fish? It's probably better to post an actual pic of the specimen in question and let someone help ID it.