PDA

View Full Version : Would a 35 gallon be good enough for a barbouri seahorse?


saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 12:32 AM
actually two barbouri seahorses, and do they go good with a clownfish?

George
04-23-2010, 01:06 AM
actually two barbouri seahorses, and do they go good with a clownfish?

I see a problem. Clownfish are pig in terms of feeding. They will steal all your food that is for your seahorses.
You better set up a dedicated tank for your seahorses.

zenafish
04-23-2010, 02:31 AM
water volume is good, but what are the dimensions of your 35gal. Remember seahorses like to have vertical swimming room just as much as horizontal.

Clownfish are fiesty and can get quite agressive during feeding and protecting their territory. I would not put any clownfish in with seahorses.

Madreefer
04-23-2010, 03:00 AM
Seahorses should be kept with there own. The clownfish will out compete them for food. They are slow movers and eaters. Mine only eat mysis shrimp and took some time to get them to eat. They need to be fed a few times a day.

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 04:22 AM
ahhh okay! and i will check some time tomorrow the height

rayjay
04-23-2010, 05:05 AM
If you don't care about breeding the seahorses, then you don't have to worry about the height of the 35g.
Height is more for the pair to be able to transfer eggs from female to male pouch during the mating dance.
DanU at seahorsesourse.com has reported egg transfers with little height, implying that sometimes they find a way anyway.

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 05:09 AM
ok since you know lots bout seahorses do you think they can be with a cleaner wrasse by any chance? and do you have any seahorses?

rayjay
04-23-2010, 03:08 PM
Well, I know some about seahorses, more than some and less than many others on the "org".
I have been a member on the seahorse.org for about 8 years but only actually keeping seahorses for a little under 5 years.
zenafish has as much knowledge or more than I do, but our experiences have been different so you would see some variation in our advice. However, a lot of basics would be the same from zenafish or from me.
I have had various problems trying to succeed with horses in reefing type situations and because of that, it has tempered the way I now keep my seahorses.
MY THOUGHTS ON SEAHORSE KEEPING (http://www.angelfire.com/ab/rayjay/seahorsekeeping.html)
I have no dwarf experience as of yet but zenafish has tons of experience with them.
At the moment I have 25 seahorses with 16 more on order from BWA.
I will also get dwarfs if BWA brings them in.
Bred by Seahorse Sanctuary in Australia, I have a pair of angustus, barbs and reidi.
I also have 14 reidi left of ones I've raised from birth from fry donated by Ryan at Big Als. The rest have sold to fund my new purchases.
I have 3 erectus and 2 comes left out of 5 and 3 respectively, with the losses happening during deworming process necessary when you don't know for sure that they are true captive bred.
I have on order, 8 reidi and 8 erectus from BWA.
As for cleaner wrasses AND cleaner shrimp, I found both to pester the seahorses, some stressed to the point they quit eating so I removed them and never tried again.
I also tried perc clownfish and some seahorses were stressed while some were not so it's hit and miss.
I've also seen reports on seahorse.org about clowns picking on seahorses once they got older, and had to be removed.
I have also seen reports on the org where clowns were never a problem.
As I see it, if there is a possibility of something stressing my horses, I won't put them in with my horses as seahorses mean too much to me.
If I want something bad enough to keep anyway, I'll put it in one of my reef tanks, or if not compatible, I'll set up a new tank for whatever it is I want bad enough.
Any advice I may give to anyone is based on MY experiences plus knowledge gained from many years of reading posts on the seahorse.org site.
That doesn't mean I'm always correct and it doesn't mean my ways are best.
It's always best to consider the varied opinions of experienced seahorse keepers and until you gain a lot of experience yourself, go with what the majority of those experienced keepers recommend.

SeaHorse_Fanatic
04-23-2010, 04:35 PM
Mine were never bothered by the clowns, even when the clowns were breeding regularly. Had them in a 35 hex and a 33g reg. However, clowns are also very slow & easy to catch once they're used to your home tank so would be easily removed if the clowns become an issue. Like RayJay stated, if you're worried, don't add them. If you're still wanting to add clowns, they are easier to catch than most other faster-swimming fish.

I have kept jawfish in my seahorse tanks with no problems (on a side note).

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 04:43 PM
okay thxs and ya i was wondering about the clowns because i have one right now and it looks kinda like a maroon clown but with more orange colour instead of the purple and for stripes there not really yellow there more white!

zenafish
04-23-2010, 04:45 PM
maroons are known for agressiveness...be careful...

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 05:02 PM
i'll post a picture, im not sure what type he is lol!

http://i919.photobucket.com/albums/ad31/he1016/photos039.png

SeaHorse_Fanatic
04-23-2010, 05:18 PM
White striped maroon. Very aggressive (will bite you!)

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 05:21 PM
oh really? i have never seen mine bite and its in there with a hippo tang, but then again the hippo tang is the alpha of the tank, so I see now, also mine isnt really aggressive towards the other fish? and when its feeding (it eats shrimp and bloodworms) anyways when its feeding it doesnt eat very fast it usually waits for the hippo tang to finsish first?

SeaHorse_Fanatic
04-23-2010, 06:21 PM
They are among the most aggressive clown species. Especially if they pair up. I've lost several corals because my big female (before i got rid of her) could pick up a 12 head frogspawn colony & chuck it into the sand, killing a couple heads each time.

They're smart enough not to pick on the alpha fish (ie. your Hippo) but towards something as slow & harmless as a seahorse, I wouldn't trust it. Could work, but I limited my clownfish/seahorse combos to Ocellaris or Percula. Skunk clowns would also be fine.

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 06:26 PM
mk thxs i'll be sure too sell it! i love him though so i'll need to find the best home as possible! also does that mean its a rare clownfish?

rayjay
04-23-2010, 06:26 PM
The hippo would not be ok with seahorses!

saltwaterseahorses
04-23-2010, 06:29 PM
ya lol i am getting rid of the hippo for sure, not just because its not good with seahorses, but because i have a 35 gallon and it should be in a 100 gallon or a 90 gallon, just if i could find a home for it though.....