PDA

View Full Version : aeration?


Aquaholic
02-14-2006, 06:10 PM
Can I rely soley on my protien skimmer for aeration? (prism hang-on)

Right now i have an air pump with 2 stones going.

Thank you

Invigor
02-14-2006, 06:19 PM
get a powerhead and have it turbulate the surface, lots of air exchange that way..given you don't have a glass lid right over top

adidas
02-14-2006, 07:20 PM
Yup use powerheads that way you have no bubbles all over. If your skimmer provides alot of surface agitation and provides enough flow, you can rely on it.

OCDP
02-14-2006, 07:21 PM
Airstones were popular for me with my FW tank. But with the Reef tanks.. it's all about powerheads. Seio's are the bang for your buck IMO, and have TONS of modifactions that can be done with them.

In short... two air stones & your skimmer really won't do.. but they will. (if that makes any sense at all) .. having some surface agitation and overall water movement is very critical in the hobby.

Aquaholic
02-14-2006, 11:40 PM
ok i got a power head, but is suface agrivation enough to supply oxogen?

It might just seem like its not, but it is?

Samw
02-15-2006, 12:04 AM
It depends on the skimmer. Most skimmers have water pumped into it (from outside the skimmer) and thus the water that returns to the tank is oxygenated well. However, closed loop skimmers like the smaller Tunze ones and of course Co-current airstone ones do not force water into it from the outside and thus the oxygenated water is very slow to return back into the tank and so your tank does not get oxygenated. Powerheads alone do not oxygenate very well unless you attach the venturi to it but that will cause too much salt spray.

I've done lots of tests with my oxygen meter to verify my claims and there is an article on RC about this.

Previously, I tested oxygen levels in my 38G tank with powerheads running and the Tunze Nano skimmer on. Within a few hours after turning off my lights, my oxygen level was below 40%. After replacing the skimmer with a Remora, my oxygen level is now 85% for the same tank all else constant. I don't believe that the powerheads made any significant impact on oxygenation in my tank with the way it is set up which is to circulate the water near the surface. I believe oxygenation in my tank at night is solely handled by my Remora at this point. I am so confident in my system now that I restocked my tank with Acroporas and Birds Nests which I could not keep before.

With your Prism, I am making an educated guess that it is enough to oxygenate your tank assuming that you don't have a gigantic tank. Air pumps won't be necessary but an emergency one that turns on automatically when the power goes out will be useful to have. Powerheads might make an impact if you have the water returning above the waterline so that it splashes. I've never tested that with my o2 meter since I don't think it is practical for me to have the salt water splashing and spraying.

Aquaholic
02-16-2006, 08:04 PM
Thank you for the info really helped