Need advice on salt and substrate

[ReganY]

Way too many brands out there. Just want to see what people recommend. I'm looking for crushed coral and salt that's good for reefing.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[Craigdillman]

Id start a poll....

[WarDog]

Id start a poll....

+1

[ReganY]

Id start a poll....
It's a good idea, unfortunately I don't even know which brands to start with. Was hoping for input.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[spit.fire]

Coarse gravel, thin layer. Don't buy the live stuff, its a rip off


As far as salt goes it depends on a lot of factors ;
What kind of corals you want to keep
How often are you going to do water changes (not how often you plan to)
Are you willing to dose
What size of tank and what kind of budget do you have
Are you premixing the day or week before or mixing before you do the water change (I don't reccomend this)

[ReganY]

Coarse gravel, thin layer. Don't buy the live stuff, its a rip off


As far as salt goes it depends on a lot of factors ;
What kind of corals you want to keep
How often are you going to do water changes (not how often you plan to)
Are you willing to dose
What size of tank and what kind of budget do you have
Are you premixing the day or week before or mixing before you do the water change (I don't reccomend this)

That's quiet the list of what ifs. Although I do plan on doing water changes once or twice a month. I would like lps and sps corals. I'd probably mix when I need to.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[WarDog]

I think people put too much emphasis on which salt to use.

[spit.fire]

I just buy whatever is expensive

[ReganY]

I think people put too much emphasis on which salt to use.
Fair enough, does that mean all salts are equal? And as the saying goes, "most expensive is not always the best". I mean there must be a balance of price vs quality right?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[spit.fire]

Fair enough, does that mean all salts are equal? And as the saying goes, "most expensive is not always the best". I mean there must be a balance of price vs quality right?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

no matter what salt you pick, someone is gonna have a bad experience story about it

if you dont premix your salt the day before tho i would recommend finding something that mixes fast

[ReganY]

Good to know. I will mix a day or two before. Time to find a big container.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[WarDog]

Every salt mix makes salt water with all the extra goodies your corals love. IO has everything you need to be successful, but you will get different readings from different buckets. I hear the Red Sea stuff is pretty consistent, but my LFS doesn't carry it. Reefers Best could have gold flake in it for all I care, and mix perfectly, but I'm not paying over $100 for a pail of salt. If you're just starting out then I'd just go with IO for now.

[ReganY]

Good to know. I am starting off with cheaper stuff but I plan to get some better quality stuff after cycle.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[The Guy]

I keep hearing that Red Sea is good, Amazon.ca has it, but the prices are all over the place. I always used IO without issues.

[reef-keeper]

I use reef crystals by IO. Suppose to have higher trace elements that reefs need. But that is what I was told. Never had a problem with it. And I find the reading very consistent.

[RDNanoGuy]

I used IO for years with zero problems. Just make sure to roll your buckets before use tho mix it up real good.

I switched to Coralife salt last year because its cheaper and alot of LFS use it keep costs down.had no problems so far.

[coolhandgoose]

I just buy whatever is expensive

That's hilarious!

I use H2Ocean.

[Myka]

I'd suggest using Instant Ocean until you find a reason not to. It's cheap and easy to find. I don't like Reef Crystals because the calcium is super high, and I don't think the difference between it and IO is worth the price difference. Both Instant Ocean and Reef Crystals have high alkalinity so that will help you out while you're not dosing. I also like H2Ocean, and have used it for years on my reef tank, but the cost keeps going up on it, and it's now a $100 bucket of salt. It's a natural seasalt though, it's not synthetic. So yeah, just stick with IO for now.

For substrate though, I would not suggest a gravel. I would go with a coarse sand like Caribsea Seaflor Special Grade or Caribsea Aragamax Select. Gravel gets too much gunk stuck in it, and fine sand blows around the tank and makes a mess.

[Simons]

I have used salinity and IO and from the two I feel IO is better from a mixing point of view. It took salinity for ever to mix in comparison at least from my experience.

I have 1 mm fine sand in my tank, I had to strategically place some rock islands to keep it from blowing around when my power heads cycle up, something to keep in mind. I knew that could be an issue, but I wanted the 'white' sand bed look in my tank so I just did some intervention before it became an issue.

I have about 1 inch of sand, so definitely not a DSB, I have heard and read many posts and articles some for DSB and some against. I think if you keep a goby or other sand sifters in your tank like I do, you should not have any issues with whatever you decide to go with.

[ReganY]

Well IO for the win. I will pick some up. I know Pisces has IO, at least I think that's what I saw the other day.

I honestly would prefer fine sand as simons mentioned. It does look nice, but yes the fact that it blows around the tank definitely dissuaded me. I have decided to get mixed crushed coral not too fine and not to coarse.

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

[vancityfella]

I started with H20cean and it's worked great! 3 months in I have sps and softies and I'm getting growth from everything. It's expensive but I'm running a 29g tank and a bucket lasts a long time. So I'm not worried about the difference in price. If your planning a sps tank I would recommend water changes more frequently, Cheers